« malingerer | Main | experiment over »

11.02.05

I live for the footnotes

I’ve been pretty sure for a while that George A. Kennedy was one of my heroes, primarily for his amazingly anal-retentive and enlightening translations of Aristotle and commentary thereupon. Now I’m totally sure. Because in Book 3 of The Rhetoric, Aristotle says this:

In poetry it is appropriate to speak of “white milk,” but in speech such things are not only rather unsuitable, but if used immoderately they convict [the writer of artificality] and make it clear that this is “poetry.” (227)
And Kennedy footnotes “white milk” like this:
Colloquial in the United States today, but Aristotle did not know about chocolate milk.

Comments

That's hilarious! I hadn't noticed!

How many times have I read Kennedy's Aristotle translation and NEVER noticed that footnote. Kudos to you for being so thorough!